We conducted a study to explore whether Echinacea purpurea, a popular herbal remedy, could help prevent ear infections in children prone to recurrent otitis media. The research involved a randomized, placebo-controlled trial where ninety young children between 12 and 60 months participated. They were divided into four groups, either receiving Echinacea with or without osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT), or placebos for both.
Over six months, we observed that treating colds with Echinacea did not significantly reduce the risk of developing acute otitis media. In fact, there is some indication that it may actually increase the risk of these infections. Similarly, the osteopathic manipulative treatments offered during the study did not provide any significant benefits in preventing ear infections either.
It's essential to take these findings seriously, as they suggest that Echinacea may not be the effective solution many parents hope for when dealing with their child's recurrent ear issues.
Read More
8
Echinacea improves ear infection outcomes
Efficacy of complex herbal compound of Echinacea angustifolia (Imoviral® Junior) in recurrent upper respiratory tract infections during pediatric age: preliminary results.
We examined the effectiveness of a herbal compound containing Echinacea angustifolia, along with several other ingredients, in treating recurrent respiratory infections among children, particularly focusing on ear infections like otitis media.
To do this, we administered this immunostimulant blend, known as Imoviral® Junior, to 37 children suffering from recurrent pharyngotonsillitis and otitis media. Over a six-month period prior to treatment, these children experienced an average of 3 episodes of inflammation. Remarkably, this number dropped to about 1 episode after the treatment began.
Furthermore, 77% of the children noticed an improvement in the frequency of their acute episodes after completing the treatment. Alongside this, their quality of life, assessed through a questionnaire, showed significant enhancement. Notably, the treatment did not lead to any adverse effects, making it a safe option for families seeking relief from recurrent infections.
Overall, the herbal compound, which includes Echinacea, beta-glucan, vitamin C, arabinogalactan, and zinc, may offer beneficial support for children dealing with recurrent ear infections and other related conditions, enhancing their overall well-being.
Read More
Most Useful Reviews
9
Quick relief
1 people found this helpful
Taking this at the first sign of a cold gives immediate relief. Unlike chemical cold remedies, this herbal option offers peace of mind.
Read More
9
Ear infection saviour
1 people found this helpful
This echinacea variant is much more effective than "Immunal" for treating colds and ENT issues, including my ear infection. I always have it in my first aid kit due to the great dosage and large quantity.
Read More
9
Infection cleared up
1 people found this helpful
I have been using echinacea for decades as an antibiotic, and it works quite well. It is more effective than prescription drugs for my costochondritis. I also administered it to my white German shepherd when she had an infected claw. Although she was on a course of prescription antibiotics, the infection persisted. After a week on echinacea, our holistic vet approved its continued use for another two weeks. Thankfully, the infection resolved, and she did not lose her claw. Echinacea is truly remarkable.
We examined the effectiveness of a herbal compound containing Echinacea angustifolia, along with several other ingredients, in treating recurrent respiratory infections among children, particularly focusing on ear infections like otitis media.
To do this, we administered this immunostimulant blend, known as Imoviral® Junior, to 37 children suffering from recurrent pharyngotonsillitis and otitis media. Over a six-month period prior to treatment, these children experienced an average of 3 episodes of inflammation. Remarkably, this number dropped to about 1 episode after the treatment began.
Furthermore, 77% of the children noticed an improvement in the frequency of their acute episodes after completing the treatment. Alongside this, their quality of life, assessed through a questionnaire, showed significant enhancement. Notably, the treatment did not lead to any adverse effects, making it a safe option for families seeking relief from recurrent infections.
Overall, the herbal compound, which includes Echinacea, beta-glucan, vitamin C, arabinogalactan, and zinc, may offer beneficial support for children dealing with recurrent ear infections and other related conditions, enhancing their overall well-being.
Read More
1
Echinacea ineffective for ear infections
Echinacea purpurea and osteopathic manipulative treatment in children with recurrent otitis media: a randomized controlled trial.
We conducted a study to explore whether Echinacea purpurea, a popular herbal remedy, could help prevent ear infections in children prone to recurrent otitis media. The research involved a randomized, placebo-controlled trial where ninety young children between 12 and 60 months participated. They were divided into four groups, either receiving Echinacea with or without osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT), or placebos for both.
Over six months, we observed that treating colds with Echinacea did not significantly reduce the risk of developing acute otitis media. In fact, there is some indication that it may actually increase the risk of these infections. Similarly, the osteopathic manipulative treatments offered during the study did not provide any significant benefits in preventing ear infections either.
It's essential to take these findings seriously, as they suggest that Echinacea may not be the effective solution many parents hope for when dealing with their child's recurrent ear issues.
Read More
User Reviews
USERS' SCORE
Good
Based on 13 Reviews
8.2
All Reviews
Positive Reviews
Negative Reviews
9
Quick relief
1 people found this helpful
Taking this at the first sign of a cold gives immediate relief. Unlike chemical cold remedies, this herbal option offers peace of mind.
Read More
9
Ear infection saviour
1 people found this helpful
This echinacea variant is much more effective than "Immunal" for treating colds and ENT issues, including my ear infection. I always have it in my first aid kit due to the great dosage and large quantity.
Read More
9
Infection cleared up
1 people found this helpful
I have been using echinacea for decades as an antibiotic, and it works quite well. It is more effective than prescription drugs for my costochondritis. I also administered it to my white German shepherd when she had an infected claw. Although she was on a course of prescription antibiotics, the infection persisted. After a week on echinacea, our holistic vet approved its continued use for another two weeks. Thankfully, the infection resolved, and she did not lose her claw. Echinacea is truly remarkable.
Read More
9
Effective for ENT
Echinacea is a miracle remedy for colds, hypothermia, and particularly for ear infections! This form is significantly more effective than the familiar "Imunal". I always keep it in my medicine cabinet, as the dosage is good and the considerably large package lasts a long time.
Read More
7.5
Quality alternative
5 people found this helpful
I switched brands but found NOW's quality effective without issues. Echinacea’s properties include immunostimulatory, antibacterial, and antiviral effects, making it beneficial against various infections, including upper respiratory and urinary system infections.
An ear infection, also known as otitis media, occurs when germs—such as bacteria or viruses—infect the middle ear, which is the space behind the eardrum. This condition can cause a variety of symptoms, including ear pain, difficulty hearing, fluid drainage from the ear, fever, and irritability in children. Ear infections are particularly common in children due to their shorter and more horizontal Eustachian tubes, which make it easier for pathogens to reach the middle ear. When the Eustachian tubes become swollen or blocked due to upper respiratory infections, allergies, or sinus infections, fluid can accumulate and lead to an infection.
Treatment typically depends on the severity and frequency of the infections. For mild cases, doctors may recommend observation, as many ear infections resolve on their own. In more severe cases, particularly when symptoms last longer than 48 hours, antibiotics may be prescribed. Pain relievers can also help manage discomfort. In cases of recurrent infections, additional interventions, such as the placement of ear tubes, might be considered. Proper hygiene and avoiding exposure to smoke can also reduce the risk of developing ear infections.
Echinacea is a genus of flowering plants in the daisy family, commonly known for its medicinal properties. There are several species within this genus, but Echinacea purpurea is perhaps the most well-known and widely used, particularly in herbal supplements aimed at supporting immune health. Traditionally, Echinacea has been used by Native American tribes for its purported benefits in fighting infections and reducing symptoms of colds and respiratory illnesses. The plant is characterized by its distinctive purple cone-shaped flowers and is also cultivated for ornamental purposes.
In contemporary use, Echinacea is typically available in various forms, including capsules, teas, extracts, and tinctures. While some studies suggest that Echinacea may help reduce the duration and severity of colds when taken at the first signs of illness, evidence remains mixed, and more research is needed to confirm its effectiveness. As always, it’s advisable to consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new supplement, especially for individuals with allergies to plants in the daisy family or those taking specific medications.
Based on user reviews, individuals taking this echinacea supplement for ear infections often report noticeable results within a matter of days. Reviewers indicate that by using the product at the first signs of infection, symptoms can typically resolve quickly, with some describing the product as effective enough to avoid antibiotics altogether. For instance, one user noted that their infection cleared up within days after switching to this echinacea variant, which they found to be significantly more effective than pharmacy options Read Review.
Additionally, users have shared positive experiences concerning the supplement's efficacy against ear infections, highlighting its benefits in bolstering the body's defenses and aiding recovery Read Review. Overall, while experiences may vary, a common sentiment among users is that quick results can often be expected when taking the supplement during the early stages of an infection.
The use of Echinacea as a supplement for ear infections, particularly in children, presents a mixed narrative based on recent scientific studies. One study indicated that a herbal compound containing Echinacea angustifolia, among other ingredients, showed promise in reducing the frequency of acute episodes of ear infections in children suffering from recurrent infections. After administering the treatment, children experienced a significant drop in the average number of episodes and reported improvements in their quality of life, suggesting that Echinacea may offer some supportive benefits in managing recurrent ear infections [1].
Conversely, another study focusing on Echinacea purpurea did not find significant benefits in preventing ear infections among children prone to recurrent otitis media. In fact, the results indicated a potential increase in the risk of developing these infections among those treated with Echinacea. This raises concerns about the efficacy and safety of using Echinacea specifically for this purpose, highlighting the need for careful consideration before using such supplements [2]. Therefore, while there is some evidence supporting the use of certain Echinacea products for ear infection relief, other research suggests potential risks, making it essential for parents to consult healthcare professionals before starting any supplement regimen.
Based on user reviews, many individuals report a range of improvements in their symptoms when using this echinacea supplement, particularly for colds, ear infections, and other respiratory issues. Users often mention that taking echinacea at the onset of their symptoms provides immediate relief, distinguishing it from traditional cold remedies. One user noted, "Taking this at the first sign of a cold gives immediate relief," highlighting the supplement's quick action Read Review. Furthermore, others emphasize its effectiveness against ear infections, with remarks on how the supplement allowed them to avoid antibiotics altogether Read Review.
Users also report positive experiences in using echinacea for various infections beyond the common cold, such as costochondritis and even for administering to pets suffering from infections. One reviewer stated that after switching to echinacea, their dog’s persistent claw infection was resolved within a week, showcasing the supplement's versatility and efficacy Read Review. Overall, while results vary from person to person, a significant number report improved immune response and quicker recovery times, solidifying echinacea's reputation as a beneficial herbal remedy for various health issues.
Based on user reviews, there are mixed experiences regarding the combination of this echinacea supplement with other treatments for ear infections. Many users report that the echinacea alone has been sufficiently effective in managing their ear infections, with some stating it resolved their symptoms within days and allowed them to avoid antibiotics altogether Read Review. Other reviewers expressed satisfaction with the supplement's efficacy for a range of infections, including ear-related issues, further reinforcing the idea that it can be a standalone remedy for those in need Read Review.
However, some users have incorporated echinacea into a broader regimen, taking it alongside traditional medications or preventative supplements. For instance, one user mentioned using echinacea alongside a course of prescription antibiotics for their dog, which ultimately led to the resolution of an infection that the antibiotics alone could not address Read Review. This suggests that while echinacea is lauded for its effectiveness, some users feel that it can complement other treatments well. Overall, although many report positive results from taking echinacea alone, those who are more inclined to adopt a multi-faceted approach may also find success in combining it with other supplements or medications.
Based on user reviews, there's a range of dosages reported for Echinacea in treating ear infections. Some users suggest taking a conservative dose initially, such as two capsules three times daily, to manage various infections effectively, including ear infections Read Review. Others recommend starting with three to four pills daily over a longer period of two to three months to achieve maximum benefits against recurring infections Read Review.
Many users emphasize that they experienced positive results when they took Echinacea at the first sign of an infection, highlighting its effectiveness in boosting the immune response and potentially resolving issues without the need for antibiotics Read Review. Some specifically noted that the dosage offered with their preferred echinacea product was sufficient and convenient, indicating that a good dosage contributes to its efficacy for conditions like ear infections Read Review.
9
Antibiotic alternative
3 people found this helpful
Initially sceptical, I found this echinacea far more effective than pharmacy options. If the infection strikes, this product resolves the issue within days, often without the need for antibiotics.
9
Effective for ENT
Echinacea is a miracle remedy for colds, hypothermia, and particularly for ear infections! This form is significantly more effective than the familiar "Imunal". I always keep it in my medicine cabinet, as the dosage is good and the considerably large package lasts a long time.
9
Quick relief
1 people found this helpful
Taking this at the first sign of a cold gives immediate relief. Unlike chemical cold remedies, this herbal option offers peace of mind.
9
Infection cleared up
1 people found this helpful
I have been using echinacea for decades as an antibiotic, and it works quite well. It is more effective than prescription drugs for my costochondritis. I also administered it to my white German shepherd when she had an infected claw. Although she was on a course of prescription antibiotics, the infection persisted. After a week on echinacea, our holistic vet approved its continued use for another two weeks. Thankfully, the infection resolved, and she did not lose her claw. Echinacea is truly remarkable.
7.5
Infection treatment
1 people found this helpful
It’s excellent for inflammation and infections, including pus-related issues. My daughter dealt with an infection caused by hair penetration, and taking two capsules three times daily resolved her problem, eliminating the need for painful surgery.
7
Recurrent HPV support
3 people found this helpful
I use this to boost my immune system against a recurrent HPV infection. Many recommend it for its quality, and with echinacea root included, it's good value for the size. I suggest taking 3-4 pills daily for a proper two to three-month supply to gain maximum benefit.
8
Echinacea improves ear infection outcomes
Efficacy of complex herbal compound of Echinacea angustifolia (Imoviral® Junior) in recurrent upper respiratory tract infections during pediatric age: preliminary results.
We examined the effectiveness of a herbal compound containing Echinacea angustifolia, along with several other ingredients, in treating recurrent respiratory infections among children, particularly focusing on ear infections like otitis media.
To do this, we administered this immunostimulant blend, known as Imoviral® Junior, to 37 children suffering from recurrent pharyngotonsillitis and otitis media. Over a six-month period prior to treatment, these children experienced an average of 3 episodes of inflammation. Remarkably, this number dropped to about 1 episode after the treatment began.
Furthermore, 77% of the children noticed an improvement in the frequency of their acute episodes after completing the treatment. Alongside this, their quality of life, assessed through a questionnaire, showed significant enhancement. Notably, the treatment did not lead to any adverse effects, making it a safe option for families seeking relief from recurrent infections.
Overall, the herbal compound, which includes Echinacea, beta-glucan, vitamin C, arabinogalactan, and zinc, may offer beneficial support for children dealing with recurrent ear infections and other related conditions, enhancing their overall well-being.
1
Echinacea ineffective for ear infections
Echinacea purpurea and osteopathic manipulative treatment in children with recurrent otitis media: a randomized controlled trial.
We conducted a study to explore whether Echinacea purpurea, a popular herbal remedy, could help prevent ear infections in children prone to recurrent otitis media. The research involved a randomized, placebo-controlled trial where ninety young children between 12 and 60 months participated. They were divided into four groups, either receiving Echinacea with or without osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT), or placebos for both.
Over six months, we observed that treating colds with Echinacea did not significantly reduce the risk of developing acute otitis media. In fact, there is some indication that it may actually increase the risk of these infections. Similarly, the osteopathic manipulative treatments offered during the study did not provide any significant benefits in preventing ear infections either.
It's essential to take these findings seriously, as they suggest that Echinacea may not be the effective solution many parents hope for when dealing with their child's recurrent ear issues.
References
Minetti AM, Forti S, Tassone G, Torretta S, Pignataro L. Efficacy of complex herbal compound of Echinacea angustifolia (Imoviral® Junior) in recurrent upper respiratory tract infections during pediatric age: preliminary results. Minerva Pediatr. 2011;63:177.
Wahl RA, Aldous MB, Worden KA, Grant KL. Echinacea purpurea and osteopathic manipulative treatment in children with recurrent otitis media: a randomized controlled trial. BMC Complement Altern Med. 2008;8:56. doi:10.1186/1472-6882-8-56